J.J. McCarthy should be back in the lineup when the Vikings take the field this weekend. According to ESPN’s Kevin Seifert, the quarterback has cleared concussion protocol and is expected to slot back into the starting lineup for Sunday’s matchup against the Commanders.
McCarthy suffered his concussion back in Week 12 and was forced to miss his team’s Week 13 loss to the Seahawks. The 2024 first-round pick seemed to be trending towards a return. Coach Kevin O’Connell told reporters earlier this week that the second-year pro was symptom free, but he had to get through Wednesday’s practice without any setbacks (per Emily Leiker of The Minnesota Star Tribune). McCarthy ended up being a full participant during that session, opening the door for his return.
As Seifert notes, the Vikings are hoping McCarthy can remain in the lineup for the remainder of the season as they evaluate his progress ahead of the 2026 campaign. O’Connell also told reporters that he’s no longer focused on his young quarterback improving mechanics, with the coaching staff instead concentrating on the player’s decision making and ability to avoid hard contact. McCarthy also suffered a high ankle sprain earlier this season that sidelined him for more than a month.
After missing his entire rookie campaign due to a torn meniscus, McCarthy has struggled during his first season as a starter. The Vikings have gone 2-4 in the QB’s six starts, with McCarthy completing only 54.1 percent of his passes while tossing six touchdowns vs. 10 interceptions. The Michigan product blamed his tendency to “overthink” things for his inconsistency.
“Just worrying about things,” he said (via Seifert). “Like on the 12th hole, you’re not going to switch up your golf swing and stuff like that. But there’s always ways to refine it. There’s always little mental cues that you’re going to take throughout that game. But yeah, the mechanics thing … it’s always going to be a continued process to grow and be as efficient as possible.”
While Vikings fans have naturally grown impatient with the QB’s progress, they got a taste of the alternative last weekend. Max Brosmer filled in for his teammate and proceeded to toss four interceptions in a shutout loss. That performance may have afforded McCarthy a bit more leeway as the starter, but the organization will be hyper focused on his play down the stretch as they determine the best path forward at the position.